


|

Paleopathology
Moderators: Dr. Marvin Allison and Dr. Enrique Gerszten
|
Section 4 -
|
Viral and Fungal Diseases in South America Before Columbus

Marvin J. Allison and Enrique Gerszten
Virginia Commonwealth University
Medical College of Virginia Campus
Richmond, Virginia, USA
|


The liver is the largest solid organ to survive in Andean natural, dried mummies; it is also
associated with most blood borne organisms since they must pass through the liver. The livers of
numerous Andean mummies also demonstrate cirrhosis when examined microscopically. Therefore the liver is
a good organ for the study of possible "persister" viruses and their association with disease in
pre-Columbian native populations. Such viruses and some fungi are chronically infective and remain in
the human host for the duration of his or her life. They may initially enter the host subclinically or
in a mild clinical state, becoming latent, and later after months or years produce a long-term cumulative
clinical disease. These organisms are rarely initially lethal (ex. Hepatitis B or Herpes
simplex), and readily become well adapted in community life.

Method:
We have reviewed the livers of 3 populations of Andean populations dating from 1,650 – 500 B.P.
looking for the "persister" viruses Hepatitis B and C, Herpes I and II, Cytomegalo virus and Epstein-Barr
virus. They were tested using Biogenex monoclonal antibodies and their Super Sensitive Immunodetection
system for Streptavidin-Biotin-Alkaline phosphatase-Fast Red to produce color of in-situ antigen detection. Modern positive and negative controls were used, and
the presence of DNA in the tissue was demonstrated with an ALU probe.

Results:
DNA was found in all livers tested in fragments of 200-400 base pairs. Viruses found in in-situ hybridization of liver sections were as follows compared with Black's
modern Amazon Indian studies performed in Brazil in 1970:

| Mummies | Modern Amazon Indians |
| HCV | 23.03 % | HCV was first described in 1989 |
| HBV | 19.35 % | 56.0% |
| HSVI | 54.84 % | No antibody available at that time |
| HSV II | 96.77 % | 95.0 % |
| CMV | 16.13% | 54.0% |
| EBV | 58.0 % | 97.0% |

Currently, HBV and HCV are common among the modern Amazon tribes. The disease is contracted early in
childhood with a pre-mature death before the age of 30. A survey of 670 Indians in 37 Amazon communities
for HBV found 59% positive with 1.8% active. Males account for 83%. Children under 10 years old were
44.26 % positive, and the chronic carrier rate in children under 5 years old was 14.9%. This is an old
disease among the pre-Columbian children where pediatric children's mummified livers were positive in
45.8%, almost identical with Black's modern figure of 44.26 % of children.

Infectious diseases with a fungal etiology have been scarce among the Andean mummies, but the
following cases have been found:

Cases 1 -The mummy of a 56-year-old woman who was found in the Arica area of Northern Chile was
autopsied at the University of Chile in Santiago. The lung in her thoracic cavity on the right side was
firmly adherent to the costal pleura. A large cavity containing blackish material from a large
hemorrhage was present in the upper lobe. The tracheobroncheal lymph nodes were 2 cm. Initially, it was
thought to be another case of tuberculosis but Kenyoun stains were negative repeatedly for acid-fast
organisms. The lung and lymph nodes were both positive for the yeast form Paracoccidiodes
brasiiliensis with numerous "Mickey Mouse" figures and "municioneras" or cartridge belt forms. The
disease of South American Blastomycosis in South America has more cases than the few hundred reported
annually. This disease is found in rural areas where good medical attention is lacking and is probably
diagnosed as tuberculosis based on an X-ray and skin test, which will be positive in 95% of the adult
population.

Case 2 – An adult woman who died of pneumonia in 1610 (Colonial Period) had lung sections stained
with H &E and Gram's stain. Her sections were positive for yeast like organisms with typical
pseudohyphae of Candida albicans. This infection today is generally associated with immunological
or endocrine diseases.

Case 3 – A 25-year-old woman who died 1,200 years ago, underwent a chest X-ray of her mummy bundle
that showed calcified tracheobroncheal lymph nodes that could have been part of a Ghon complex, but no
primary lesion was present. When she was unwrapped she was found to have extensive nodular lesions of
her right breast with a few nodules in her left breast. She was autopsied and found to have just
delivered a baby and bled to death from the delivery. Sections of the breast lesion had numerous
spheroides and endospores of Coccidiodes immitis. A review of her information suggests that the
calcified lung lymph nodes were due to a primary pneumonia of coccidioidomycosis, which was self-healing,
only to be reactivated due to her pregnancy. The disease spread to the active tissues of her breast as a
result of her pregnancy and the coccidioidomycosis may have caused spontaneous abortion, resulting in her
death. This case is the first such case in Peru although there are scatterings of cases in Argentina
since the first case was reported there in 1892. There are a few cases reported from other South
American countries, but the disease is much more frequent in the United States where in some geographic
locations 1:3 people are skin positive. Why are so few cases found in South America when much of the
geographic area is similar to California where the fungus is a common soil organism? In rural South
America medical attention is minimal and most cases are misdiagnosed by radiography as tuberculosis.

Conclusion:
Modern laboratory technology can be used to accurately diagnose viral and fungal diseases even in
tissues thousand of years old, thus demonstrating diseases in ancient civilization.

Bibliography
- Allison Marvin J, Gerszten Enrique, Martinez A. Julio, Klurfeld David - Generalized Connective Tissue Disease in a Mummy from the Huari Culture (Peru) . Bull.N.Y.Acad.Med. 53, 292-301,1977

- Chou Shi-Ming – Myxovirus-Like Structures in a Case of Human Chronic Polymyositis. Science 158, 1453-1455, 1967

- Gyorkey F., Min K.W., Sinkovics J.G., and Gyorkey P. - Systemic Lupus Erythematosus and Myxovirus. New Engl.J.Med. 280, 333, 1969

- Black Francis – Infectious Diseases in Primitive Societies. Science, 187, 515-518, 1975

- Black Francis L., Hierholzer Walter J., Pinheiro Francisco deP, Evans Alfred S., Woodall John P., Opton Edward M., West Bernice S., Edsall Geoffrey, Doens Wilbur G., and Wallace Gordon D. – Evidence for Persistence of Infectious Agents in Isolated Human Populations. Amer.J.Epid. 100, 230-250, 1974

- Black F.L., Woodall J.P., Evans A.S., Liebhaber H., and Henle Gertrude- Prevalence of Antibody Against Virus in the Tiriyo, and Isolated Amazon Tribe. Amer. J. Epidemiology 91, 430-438, 1970

- Neel James V., Andrade Amelia H.P., Brown Gordon E., Eveland Warren E., Goolbar Jorge, Sodeman Jr. William A., Stollerman Gene H., Weinstein David, Wheeler A.H. – Further Studies of the Xavante Indians. Amer. J. Trop. Med. And Hygiene 17, 486-498, 1968

- Fields Bernard N. et al 770, 1 Field's Virology Vol.2, Chapter 86, Hepatitis B Virus, Epidemiology, Pgs. 2761-2996 Lippencott-Raven, Philadelphia

- Roache Patrick C. and His Eric D. Immunohistochemistry: Theory and Practice Chapter 13, Pg 229-238. Morphology Methods, Cell and Molecular Biology Techniques, Ed.

- Jin Long, Qian Xiang, and Lloyd Ricardo, In Situ Hybridization: Detection of DNA and RNA, Chapter 3, Pg 27-46

- Rauba Linas; Coccidioidomycosis: http://www.emedicine.com/coccidioidomycosis 2005

- Posada A.: Un Nuevo Caso de Micosis Fungoidea con Psorspermias Ann. Cir. Med. Argent. 1892 15: 585

- Rixford Emmet and Gilchrist T.C.: Two Cases of Protozoan (Coccidioidal ) infection of the skin and Other Organs John Hopkins Hospital Report 1896 1, 209

- Ophuls W.: Further Observations on a Pathologenic Mould formerly Described as a Protozoon (Coccidioides immitis, Coccidioides pyogenes) J.Exp. Med. 1905 6, 443

- Dickson Ernest C. and Gifford Myrnie A.: Coccidioides Infection (Coccidioidomycosis) III The Primary Type of Infection Arch. Int, Med 1938 62, 853

- Drutz David J., and Calanzaro Antonio: State of the Art Coccidioidomycosis Part I Amer. Rev. Resp. Dis. 1978 117, 559 - 585 Part II Amer. Rev. Resp. Dis. 1978 117 727 – 771

- Fernandez Ibarguen Manuel: Estudio de la Coccidioidomicosis en la Amazonia Peruana. Lima, Thesis 1970 PE1, 1, TD-UPCH WC 460 F38

- CDC Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, Emerging Infectious Diseases: Coccidioidomycosis Following the Northridge earthquake – California 1994 March 18, 1994

- Maddy R.T.: The Geographic Distribution of Coccidioides immitis and Possible Ecologic Implications, Ariz Med 1958 15, 178

- Moraes Mario A. P., Martins Ricardo Ruiz, Rama Leal Isabel Irene, Rocha Inesila, Schittini and Medeiros Jr. Pedro: Coccidioidomicosis: Novo Caso Brasileiro Revista da Socoiedade Brasileira de Medicina Tropical, 1998 31, 559-562

- Harris R.E.: Coccidioidomycosis Complicating Pregnancy. Report of three Cases and Review of the Literature, Obstet Gynacol 1966 28, 401
|


|
|
|